Isabel vs Raquel: Comparing Two Modern American Girl Dolls

American Girl has introduced many beloved characters over the years, but two of the most exciting modern dolls are Isabel and Raquel. While both are 18-inch dolls with beautiful stories and accessories, they come from different lines: Isabel is a contemporary character with a journal and carrier set, while Raquel is the 2026 Girl of the Year with a sporty pickleball theme. If you're trying to choose between them, this comparison will help you understand their unique features, play styles, and which one might be the perfect addition to your doll family.

We'll look at their stories, included accessories, outfit options, and overall play value. Whether you're a collector or a parent looking for a gift, you'll find all the details you need to make an informed decision.

Character Background and Story

Isabel is a contemporary American Girl doll who represents the modern, creative spirit of today's girls. She comes with a journal that allows her owner to document adventures, dreams, and daily life. The NickiTM 18-inch Doll, Journal, Accessories & Doll Carrier set is perfect for girls who love storytelling and imaginative play. Isabel's story encourages self-expression and friendship.

Raquel, on the other hand, is the Girl of the Year for 2026. She is an active, sporty character who loves pickleball and spending time with friends. Her story focuses on teamwork, perseverance, and having fun. The Raquel'sTM Pickleball Set (Girl of the YearTM 2026) includes everything needed for a pickleball game, making her ideal for girls who enjoy sports and outdoor activities.

• Isabel: contemporary character, journal included, encourages creativity.
• Raquel: Girl of the Year 2026, sporty theme, emphasizes teamwork.

Included Accessories and Play Value

When comparing what comes with each doll, Isabel's set is comprehensive. The NickiTM 18-inch Doll, Journal, Accessories & Doll Carrier includes a doll carrier for easy transport, a journal for writing, and various accessories like a hairbrush and backpack. This makes it a great all-in-one set for girls who want to take their doll on the go.

Raquel's set focuses on her favorite sport. The Raquel'sTM Pickleball Set (Girl of the YearTM 2026) includes a pickleball paddle, ball, and net, plus a sporty outfit and sneakers. For girls who love active play, this set offers a unique theme that encourages physical activity and imaginative sports games. Both dolls offer high play value, but in different ways.

• Isabel: includes doll carrier, journal, hairbrush, backpack.
• Raquel: includes pickleball paddle, ball, net, sporty outfit and shoes.

Outfits and Fashion Options

Fashion is a big part of American Girl play, and both dolls have stylish options. Isabel's outfit is a trendy, everyday look with a colorful top, jeans, and sneakers. She can also be dressed in additional outfits like the October Opal Obsession Outfit for 18-inch Dolls, which adds a touch of glamour with a sparkly dress and accessories.

Raquel's outfit is sporty and functional, perfect for pickleball. She wears a athletic top, shorts, and sneakers. For more casual looks, the AG SistersTM School Style Fashion Set can be a great addition, offering a school-themed outfit that works for both dolls. Both dolls can wear a wide range of American Girl clothing, so fashion lovers will have plenty of choices.

• Isabel: everyday trendy look; can wear October Opal Obsession Outfit.
• Raquel: sporty athletic wear; compatible with AG Sisters School Style Fashion Set.

Which Doll Should You Choose?

Choosing between Isabel and Raquel depends on your child's interests. If she loves writing, storytelling, and taking her doll on adventures, Isabel is an excellent choice. The journal and carrier set encourage creative play and make it easy to bring the doll along. Isabel's contemporary style also makes her a versatile addition to any doll collection.

If your child is active, enjoys sports, or is excited about pickleball, Raquel is the perfect pick. As the 2026 Girl of the Year, she represents a special moment in time and comes with a unique sports set that encourages outdoor play. Both dolls are high-quality 18-inch dolls with beautiful hair and posable bodies, so you can't go wrong with either.

• Choose Isabel for creative, on-the-go play with journal and carrier.
• Choose Raquel for sporty, active play with pickleball set.

Ultimately, both Isabel and Raquel offer wonderful play experiences. If you're still unsure, consider starting with the NickiTM 18-inch Doll, Journal, Accessories & Doll Carrier for its versatility and storytelling potential. Whichever you choose, your child will love the imaginative adventures that await.